Professor Richard Houlston
Head of Division: Cancer Genomics
OrcID: 0000-0002-5268-0242
Phone: +44 20 8722 4175
Email: [email protected]
Also on: https://www.houlston.group
Location: Sutton
OrcID: 0000-0002-5268-0242
Phone: +44 20 8722 4175
Email: [email protected]
Also on: https://www.houlston.group
Location: SuttonBiography
Richard Houlston graduated with distinction in Medicine from Imperial College London, gaining MD and PhD degrees from the University of London. Following various medical internships and Fellowships he joined the Institute of Cancer Research in 1994. In 2017, Professor Houlston’s outstanding contributions to the field of cancer genetics were recognised with his election as a Fellow to The Royal Society.
See all news stories on our website that feature the work of Professor Houlston and colleagues.
BSc Biochemistry, Imperial College, London.
MB BS, Imperial College, London.
MSc, Institute of Psychiatry, University of London.
MD, PhD Genetics, University of London.
MRCPath, Royal College of Pathologists.
FRCPath, Royal College of Pathologists.
MRCP, Royal College of Physicians.
FRCP, Royal College of Physicians.
DSc, Imperial College, London.
Fellowship, Society of Biologists, 2011.
Fellowship European Academy of Cancer Sciences, ECCO, 2015.
FRS, The Royal Society, 2017.
Editorial BoardsBritish Journal of Cancer, Editor: Genetics & Genomics, 2003.
International Journal of Cancer, 2013.
Scientific Reports, 2015.
Cancer Family Study Group, Member, , 1992-1995; 2005-2009.
Steering Committee, Member, UKCCS, 2006.
Academic Board, Member, Institute of Cancer Research, 2001.
Joint Research Committee, Member, Institute of Cancer Research-Royal Marsden Hospital NHS Trust, 2002.
Integrating knowledge of inherited genetic variation and acquired somatic alterations in cancer tissues: promising scientific opportunities, Member, NIH, Washington, 2009-2009.
Cell and Molecular Biology Board, Board Member, MRC, 2014.
Related pages
Types of Publications
Journal articles
Recent genome-wide association data have implicated genetic variation at 7p12.2 (IKZF1), 10q21.2 (ARIDB5), and 14q11.2 (CEBPE) in the etiology of B-cell childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). To verify and further examine the relationship between these variants and ALL risk, we genotyped 1384 cases of precursor B-cell childhood ALL and 1877 controls from Germany and the United Kingdom. The combined data provided statistically significant support for an association between genotype at each of these loci and ALL risk; odds ratios (OR), 1.69 (P = 7.51 x10(-22)), 1.80 (P = 5.90 x 10(-28)), and 1.27 (P = 4.90 x 10(-6)), respectively. Furthermore, the risk of ALL increases with an increasing numbers of variant alleles for the 3 loci (OR(per-allele) = 1.53, 95% confidence interval, 1.44-1.62; P(trend) = 3.49 x 10(-42)), consistent with a polygenic model of disease susceptibility. These data provide unambiguous evidence for the role of these variants in defining ALL risk underscoring approximately 64% of cases.
Little is known about the relative contributions of genetic and environmental factors to the development of gastric cancer. Mutations in the cell adhesion molecule E-cadherin are recognized to be associated with the development of undifferentiated, diffuse and invasive gastric cancers. A recent study of two gastric cancer families has shown that germline mutations in the E-cadherin gene can be causative (Guilford P et al, Nature 1998; 26: 402-405). We have examined the E-cadherin gene for constitutive mutations in a systematic series of 106 gastric cancer patients, 10 with a family history of the disease and 96 sporadic cases. No pathogenic mutations were observed in any of the 106 patients. The results indicate that germline mutations in E-cadherin will not account for more than 3% of gastric cancers.
Uveal melanoma is the most common primary intraocular malignancy, with an annual incidence of 6 per million. The environmental factors known to increase the risk of cutaneous melanoma appear to be less important in ocular melanoma and it is conceivable that host factors have a greater impact. The coexistence of ocular and cutaneous melanoma in some patients suggests a predisposition to both types and implicates mutations in the CDKN2A gene in a proportion of these cases. An association between ocular melanoma and breast and/or ovarian cancer has also been reported and recent studies of breast cancer families strongly implicate BRCA2 as a predisposition gene. Other more common genes predisposing to ocular melanoma may be of low penetrance. An example of a gene in this class is MC1R, which affects host response to ultraviolet radiation. Identification of genes conferring an increased risk of ocular melanoma should provide insights into the pathogenesis of this tumour. Furthermore, it offers an opportunity to identify individuals at a high risk who may benefit from targeted surveillance. At present the identification of such individuals is restricted to the small number belonging to BRCA2 families and those with the atypical mole syndrome.
Bcl10 is a recently identified gene reported to be involved commonly in human malignancy (Willis et al (1999) Cell 96: 1-20). To investigate whether it is frequently mutated in colorectal cancer we have analysed a series of 132 colorectal cancers and eight colorectal cancer cell lines for mutations in Bcl10. One feature of the Bcl10 gene is that it harbours two polyadenine tracts. These repeating elements in genes can be prone to a high rate of mutation if there is defective mismatch repair. To examine the possibility that Bcl10 may be preferentially mutated in mismatch repair-deficient cancers, 49 of the tumours and cell lines were known to be replication error (RER)-positive and, of these, ten were from individuals harbouring germline mutations in hMLH1 or hMSH2. No pathogenic mutations were detected in the tumours and only one mutation was found in the colorectal cancer cell lines. These results indicate that Bcl10 is unlikely to be involved in the pathways of colorectal carcinogenesis.
Susceptibility to coeliac disease is genetically determined by possession of specific HLA-DQ alleles, acting in concert with one or more non-HLA linked genes. The pattern of risk seen in sibs and twins in coeliac disease is most parsimonious with a multiplicative model for the interaction between the two classes of genes. Based on a sib recurrence risk for coeliac disease of 10% and a population prevalence of 0.0033, the sib relative risk is 30. To evaluate the contribution of the MHC region to the familial risk of coeliac disease, we have examined haplotype sharing probabilities across this region in 55 coeliac disease families. Based on these probabilities the sib relative risk of coeliac disease associated with the MHC region is 3.7. Combining these results with published data on allele sharing at HLA, the estimated sib relative risk associated with the MHC region is 3.3. Therefore, the MHC genes contribute no more than 40% of the sib familial risk of coeliac disease and the non-HLA linked gene (or genes) are likely to be the stronger determinant of coeliac disease susceptibility.
B cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) shows evidence of familial aggregation, but the inherited basis is poorly understood. Mutations in the ATM gene have been demonstrated in CLL. This, coupled with a possibly increased risk of leukaemia in relatives of patients with Ataxia Telangiectasia, led us to question whether the ATM gene is involved in familial cases of CLL. To examine this proposition we typed five markers on chromosome 11q in 24 CLL families. No evidence for linkage between CLL and ATM in the 24 families studied and the best estimates of the proportion of sibling pairs that share no, one or both haplotypes at ATM were not different from their null expectations. This would imply that ATM is unlikely to make a significant contribution to the three-fold increase in risk of CLL seen in relatives of patients.
BACKGROUND: Susceptibility to coeliac disease is genetically determined by possession of specific HLA DQ alleles, acting in concert with one or more non-HLA linked genes. The pattern of familial risk is most parsimonious with a multiplicative model for the interaction between these two classes of genes. Haplotype sharing probabilities across the HLA region in affected sibling pairs suggest that genes within the MHC complex contribute no more than 40% of the sibling familial risk of coeliac disease, making the non-HLA linked gene (or genes) the stronger determinant of coeliac disease susceptibility. Attempts to localise these non-HLA linked genes have been carried out using both linkage and association tests. AIMS: To review the evidence for the involvement of non-HLA linked genes in coeliac disease, and to compare the relative merits of linkage and transmission disequilibrium tests (TDT) to detect the non-HLA linked gene (or genes) contributing to the development of coeliac disease. METHODS: Under a range of genetic models the number of affected sibling pairs needed to detect linkage was compared with the number of families required to show a relation between marker and disease, adopting the TDT strategy. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Power calculations show that, if there is a single major non-HLA linked susceptibility locus, a non-parametric linkage approach may well prove effective. However, if there are a number of non-HLA susceptibility genes, each with small effect, the sample size necessary for linkage studies will be prohibitive and a systematic search for allelic association should be a more effective strategy.
Bcl10 is a cancer gene recently identified in B-cell lymphomas of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissues. It has been suggested as a target for mutation in multiple types of tumour including follicular lymphoma, T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia and Sezary syndrome. To evaluate further the role of Bcl10 in human adult haematological cancers, we screened for mutations samples from 24 patients with B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) and 18 samples from patients with T-cell prolymphocytic leukaemia (T-PLL). No pathogenic mutations were detected in any of the samples analysed, strongly suggesting that Bcl10 is not involved in the development of CLL or T-PLL and that its involvement may be restricted to other haematological malignancies.
T cell prolymphocytic leukaemia (T-PLL) is a chronic mature T cell malignancy with many random cytogenetic abnormalities. These imply that maintenance of genomic integrity is impaired. This is supported by the recent finding that the ataxia telangiectasia gene, ATM, which contributes to maintaining genomic integrity, is frequently mutated in this disease. To evaluate in T-PLL the role of other genes with comparable function, a fluorescence-based semi-automated assay was developed for BAT-25 and BAT-26. These markers contain sequences that are particularly unstable in cells with DNA mismatch repair defects. Application of the assay to 20 T-PLL cases found no evidence for such defects.
The Li-Fraumeni syndrome (LFS) is a dominant disease whose hallmark is an increased risk of breast cancers, brain tumours, sarcomas, leukaemia and adrenal carcinoma. Some, but not all LFS and Li-Fraumeni-like (LFL) families are caused by TP53 mutations. Bcl10 is a recently identified tumour suppressor reported to be commonly mutated in a wide range of cancers. To investigate the possibility that Bcl10 is a susceptibility gene for LFS and LFL we have analysed 27 LFS/LFL families. No mutations were observed. This indicates that Bcl10 is unlikely to act as a susceptibility gene for LFS and LFL.
Lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS) is an unusual histological pattern of non-invasive neoplastic disease of the breast occurring predominantly in women aged between 40 and 50 years. LCIS is frequently multicentric and bilateral, and there is evidence that it is associated with an elevated familial risk of breast cancer. Although women with LCIS suffer an increased risk of invasive breast disease, this risk is moderate suggesting that LCIS may result from mutation of a gene or genes conferring a high risk of LCIS, but a lower risk of invasive breast cancer. The high frequency of somatic mutations in E-cadherin in LCIS, coupled with recent reports that germline mutations in this gene can predispose to diffuse gastric cancer, raised the possibility that constitutional E-cadherin mutations may confer susceptibility to LCIS. In order to explore this possibility we have examined a series of 65 LCIS patients for germline E-cadherin mutations. Four polymorphisms were detected but no pathogenic mutations were identified. The results indicate that E-cadherin is unlikely to act as a susceptibility gene for LCIS.
The search for the genes responsible for many complex genetic diseases is well under way and has already been successful in some cases. The study of cancer as a complex genetic disease has lagged behind other conditions, largely because of particular problems that are associated with malignant disease. Cancer also, however, presents specific opportunities for gene identification, which are not found in many other diseases. While the methods of genetic mapping and gene cloning used for other complex diseases will be applied to cancer, these must almost certainly be complemented by other methods, such as the study of somatic mutations, cancer associated phenotypes, and modifier genes for Mendelian cancers. Here, we review the strategies available for identifying cancer predisposition genes of low and moderate penetrance.
Approximately 13% of colorectal cancers display microsatellite instability (MSI), a form of replication error repair. Colorectal cancers developing in individuals with constitutional defects in the mismatch repair (MMR) genes hMLH1, hMSH2, hPMS1 and hPMS2 consistently show evidence of this phenomenon. Since MSI is indicative of MMR deficiency, testing colorectal cancers for MSI provides a method of refining the identification of carriers of germline MMR mutations. To assess which microsatellites represent the best reporters of replication error (RER) status we have examined 116 early onset colorectal cancers for MSI. MSI was assessed using eight dinucleotide- and two mononucleotide-repeat fluorescently labelled polymerase chain reaction (PCR) markers. The two mononucleotide repeat markers (BAT25 and BAT26) were highly sensitive and typing of either represents an efficient strategy for defining RER status of colorectal cancers and obviates the requirement of typing numerous microsatellite markers.
Interindividual differences in lung cancer susceptibility may be mediated in part through polymorphic variability in the bioactivation of procarcinogens. GSTM1 status has been extensively studied in this context as a lung cancer risk factor, although published studies have produced conflicting results. To clarify the impact of GSTM1 status on lung cancer risk a meta-analysis of 23 case-control studies from the literature has been carried out using a random effects model. The principal outcome measure was the odds ratio for the risk of lung cancer. There was heterogeneity between the studies attributable to differences in the methods of assigning GSTM1 status. Pooling the studies that were based on phenotyping methods, the overall odds ratio of lung cancer risk associated with GSTM1 deficiency was 2.12 (95% confidence interval, 1.43-3.13). The risk of lung cancer risk associated with GSTM1 deficiency derived from the studies based on genotyping methods was, however, lower. The overall odds ratio was 1.13 (95% confidence interval, 1.04-1.25). These findings suggest that the estimates of lung cancer risk associated with GSTM1 deficiency in the early studies, based on phenotyping, were overinflated. Moreover, it is conceivable, given publication bias, that GSTM1 status has no effect on the risk of lung cancer per se. A major concern in case-control studies of polymorphisms and cancer risk is bias. A review of the 23 case-control studies indicates that greater attention should, therefore, be paid to the design of future studies.
To examine the risk of lung cancer associated with the MspI-restriction fragment length polymorphism and Exon7-Val polymorphisms of CYP1A1, a meta-analysis of published case-control studies was undertaken using a random effects model. The principal outcome measure was the odds ratio for the risk of lung cancer, using homozygosity of the 'wild-type allele' as the reference group. Fifteen reports detailing the relationship between the lung cancer and the MspI and Ile-Val polymorphisms of CYP1A1 were identified. The odds ratio of lung cancer associated with the MspI combined variant and homozygous genotypes were 1.09 (0.94-1.25) and 1.27 (0.91-1.77), respectively. The odds ratio of lung cancer associated with the Ile-Val combined variant and homozygous genotypes were 1.16 (0.92-1.48) and 1.62 (0.93-2.82), respectively. The hypothesis that the modulation of carcinogen metabolism is under genetic control is a plausible and attractive mechanism for explaining inter-individual susceptibility of lung cancer. However, the results from this analysis provide little support for the role of variation in the CYP1A1 gene defined by either polymorphisms represents as lung cancer risk factor. Additional well-designed studies based on sample sizes commensurate with the detection of small genotypic risks may allow a more definitive conclusion.
BACKGROUND: Juvenile polyposis syndrome (JPS) is characterised by gastrointestinal (GI) hamartomatous polyposis and an increased risk of GI malignancy. Juvenile polyps also occur in the Cowden (CS), Bannayan-Ruvalcaba-Riley (BRRS) and Gorlin (GS) syndromes. Diagnosing JPS can be problematic because it relies on exclusion of CS, BRRS, and GS. Germline mutations in the PTCH, PTEN and DPC4 (SMAD4) genes can cause GS, CS/BRRS, and JPS, respectively. AIMS: To examine the contribution of mutations in PTCH, PTEN, and DPC4 (SMAD4) to JPS. METHODS: Forty seven individuals from 15 families and nine apparently sporadic cases with JPS were screened for germline mutations in DPC4, PTEN, and PTCH. RESULTS: No patient had a mutation in PTEN or PTCH. Five different germline mutations were detected in DPC4; three of these were deletions, one a single base substitution creating a stop codon, and one a missense change. None of these patients had distinguishing clinical features. CONCLUSIONS: Mutations in PTEN and PTCH are unlikely to cause juvenile polyposis in the absence of clinical features indicative of CS, BRRS, or GS. A proportion of JPS patients harbour DPC4 mutations (21% in this study) but there remains uncharacterized genetic heterogeneity in JPS.
B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) is the most common form of leukaemia. To gain insight into the role of inherited factors in the disease, we have conducted a survey of the family histories of 268 CLL patients and have reviewed published familial cases and epidemiological studies. The results of our survey and published studies strongly support the hypothesis that a subset of the disease can be ascribed to a genetic predisposition. The most likely genetic model for inherited predisposition appears to be dominantly acting genes with pleiotropic effects because in many families CLL appears to be associated with other lymphoproliferative disorders.
Inter-individual differences in bladder cancer susceptibility may be mediated in part through polymorphic variability in the bioactivation and detoxification of procarcinogens. Glutathione S-transferase mu1 (GSTM1) status has been extensively studied as a risk factor in this context. To clarify the impact of GSTM1 deficiency on bladder cancer risk a meta-analysis of 15 case-control studies from the literature has been carried out using a random effects model. The principal outcome measure was the odds ratio for the risk of bladder cancer. Pooling the studies the odds ratio of bladder cancer risk associated with GSTM1 deficiency was 1.53 (95% confidence limits 1.28-1.84). The relationship between GSTM1 status and bladder cancer risk was not confined to a specific population. This meta-analysis supports the hypothesis that GSTM1 deficiency is a determinant of bladder cancer susceptibility. A review of studies does, however, indicate that greater attention should therefore be paid to the design of future studies. The interaction between GSTM1 and other polymorphisms on the risk of bladder cancer and their interaction with environmental risk factors will only be addressed by well-designed studies based on sample sizes commensurate with the detection of small genotypic risks.
Interindividual differences in bladder cancer susceptibility may be partly mediated through polymorphic variability in the metabolism of carcinogens. N-acetyl transferase-2 (NAT2) has been extensively studied as a risk factor in this context, but the results are inconsistent. In some studies the failure to demonstrate a relationship may be a consequence of a lack of statistical power. To overcome lack of power, data from 21 published case-control studies were pooled in a meta-analysis using a random-effects model. The pooled odds ratio of bladder cancer associated with slow acetylator status was 1.31 (95% CI: 1.11-1.55). The results suggest that NAT2 slow acetylator status is associated with a modest increase in risk of bladder cancer. There was, however, heterogeneity between studies. It is clear from this overview that greater attention should be paid to the design of these types of study.
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) shows evidence of familial aggregation, but the genetic basis is poorly understood. The existence of a linkage between HLA and Hodgkin lymphoma, another B-cell disorder, coupled with the fact that CLL is frequently associated with autoimmune disease, led to the question of whether the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) region is involved in familial cases of CLL. To examine this proposition, 5 microsatellite markers on chromosome 6p21.3 were typed in 28 families with CLL, 4 families with CLL in association with other lymphoproliferative disorders, and 1 family with splenic lymphoma with villous lymphocytes. There was no evidence of linkage in these families to chromosome 6p21.3. The best estimates of the proportions of sibling pairs with CLL that share 0, 1, or 2 MHC haplotypes were not significantly different from the null expectation. This implies that genes within the MHC region are unlikely to be the major determinants of familial CLL. (Blood. 2000;96:3982-3984)
INTRODUCTION AND METHODS: Since the concept of the "two hit hypothesis" was introduced over 20 years ago, a wealth of genetic data has accumulated on the mutations found at tumour suppressor loci. Perhaps surprisingly, these data conceal large gaps in our knowledge which genetic and functional studies are beginning to uncover. The "two hit hypothesis" must be updated to take account of this new information. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: Here, we discuss both the results of recent studies and some of the questions that they highlight. In particular, how valid are conclusions from inherited Mendelian syndromes when applied to sporadic cancers? Why is allelic loss so common and how does it occur? Are the "two hits" random or interdependent? Is abolition of protein function always optimal for tumorigenesis? Can "third hits" occur and, if so, why? How can mismatch repair deficiency and the methylator phenotype be incorporated into the "two hit" hypothesis? We suggest that the "two hit hypothesis" is not fixed but is evolving as our knowledge expands.
With current advances in genetics it is now possible to routinely screen the entire genome of multiple affected individuals in the search for disease predisposition genes. Such a large-scale undertaking requires some careful management of both samples and data in order to make best use of all available information. Here we have detailed the two main approaches to a genome-wide search and the best ways we have found of storing, transforming, and analyzing the subsequently produced data, as well as some general considerations to enhance the chances of success.
Dominant transmission of multiple uterine and cutaneous smooth-muscle tumors is seen in the disorder multiple leiomyomatosis (ML). We undertook a genomewide screen of 11 families segregating ML and found evidence for linkage to chromosome 1q42.3-q43 (maximum multipoint LOD score 5.40). Haplotype construction and analysis of recombinations permitted the minimal interval containing the locus, which we have designated "MCUL1," to be refined to an approximately 14-cM region flanked by markers D1S517 and D1S2842. Allelic-loss studies of tumors indicated that MCUL1 may act as a tumor suppressor. Identification of MCUL1 should have wide interest, since this gene may harbor low-penetrance variants predisposing to the common form of uterine fibroids and/or may undergo somatic mutation in sporadic leiomyomata.
Peutz-Jeghers syndrome (PJS) and juvenile polyposis (JPS) are both characterized by the presence of hamartomatous polyps and increased risk of malignancy in the gastrointestinal tract. Mutations of the LKB1 and SMAD4 genes have been shown recently to cause a number of PJS and JPS cases respectively, but there remains considerable uncharacterized genetic heterogeneity in these syndromes, particularly JPS. The mouse homologue of CDX2 has been shown to give rise to a phenotype which includes hamartomatous-like polyps in the colon and is therefore a good candidate for JPS and PJS cases which are not accounted for by the SMAD4 and LKB1 genes. By analogy with SMAD4, CDX2 is also a candidate for somatic mutation in sporadic colorectal cancer. We have screened 37 JPS families/cases without known SMAD4 mutations, 10 Peutz-Jeghers cases without known LKB1 mutations and 49 sporadic colorectal cancers for mutations in CDX2. Although polymorphic variants and rare variants of unlikely significance were detected, no pathogenic CDX2 mutations were found in any case of JPS or PJS, or in any of the sporadic cancers.
Lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS) is an unusual histological pattern of non-invasive neoplastic disease of the breast occurring predominantly in women aged between 40 and 50 years. LCIS is frequently multicentric and bilateral suggesting a genetic basis to the disease. The high frequency of microsatellite instability in lobular breast cancers, coupled with increased risk of breast cancer associated with germline mismatch repair gene mutations raises the possibility that mutations MSH2 or MLH1 might confer susceptibility to LCIS. To explore this possibility we have examined a series of 71 LCIS patients for germline MSH2 and MLH1 mutations. No mutations were detected in MSH2. Two sequence variants were identified in MLH1. The first was a CTT-->CAT substitution, codon 607 (exon 16) changing leucine to histidine. The other mutation detected in MLH1 was a TAC-->TAA substitution codon 750 (exon 19) creating a stop codon, predicted to generate a truncated protein. These findings suggest that mutations in MLH1 may underlie a subset of LCIS cases.
Colorectal cancers with DNA mismatch repair (MMR) gene mutations characteristically display a high rate of replication errors in simple repetitive sequences detectable as microsatellite instability (MSI). Most are the result of somatic MMR dysfunction; however, a subset are caused by germline mutations. The availability of commercial antibodies for MSH2 and MLH1 [corrected] offers an alternative strategy to molecular methods for identifying MMR deficient cancers. To evaluate immunohistochemistry, MLH1 and MSH2 expression was studied using monoclonal antibodies in formalin fixed, paraffin wax embedded cancers. The immunohistochemical staining patterns of 23 cancers displaying MSI, including four cases with germline mutations, were compared with 23 microsatellite stable (MSS) cancers. All MSS cancers exhibited staining with both antibodies. Twenty two of the MSI cases showed absent MMR expression with either anti-MSH2 or anti-MLH1 [corrected]. The high sensitivity and predictive value of immunohistochemistry in detecting MMR deficiency offers a method of discriminating between MSI and MSS cancers caused by MSH2 and MLH1 [corrected] dysfunction. The application and suitability of immunohistochemistry for the detection of MSI and as a strategy for prioritising the mutational analysis of MMR genes in routine clinical practice is discussed.
The hereditary spastic paraplegias (HSPs) are a complex group of neurodegenerative disorders characterized by lower-limb spasticity and weakness. Silver syndrome (SS) is a particularly disabling dominantly inherited form of HSP, complicated by amyotrophy of the hand muscles. Having excluded the multiple known HSP loci, we undertook a genomewide screen for linkage of SS in one large multigenerational family, which revealed evidence for linkage of the SS locus, which we have designated "SPG17," to chromosome 11q12-q14. Haplotype construction and analysis of recombination events permitted the minimal interval defining SPG17 to be refined to approximately 13 cM, flanked by markers D11S1765 and D11S4136. SS in a second family was not linked to SPG17, demonstrating further genetic heterogeneity in HSP, even within this clinically distinct subtype.
The contribution of molecular genetics to colorectal cancer has been largely restricted to relatively rare inherited tumours and to the detection of germ line mutations predisposing to these cancers. However, much is now known about the somatic events leading to colorectal cancer in general. Several studies have examined the relation between genetic features and prognosis. The purpose of this article is to review these studies and summarise the current state of this subject. Although many of the published studies are small and inconclusive, it is clear that several different pathways exist for the development of this cancer, and some molecular characteristics seem to correlate with clinicopathological features. At present, studies are confined to evaluating a small number of molecular markers; however, with the advent of methods for the rapid genetic profiling of large numbers of colorectal cancers, it will be possible to evaluate fully the clinical usefulness of a range of colorectal cancer genotypes.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Increasingly, studies of the relationship between common genetic variants and colorectal tumor risk are being proposed. To assess the evidence that any of these confers a risk, a systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies was undertaken. METHODS: Fifty studies of the effect of common alleles of 13 genes on risk were identified. To clarify the impact of individual polymorphisms on risk, pooled analyses were performed. RESULTS: Of the 50 studies identified, significant associations were seen in 16, but only 3 were reported in more than one study. Pooling studies, significant associations were only seen for 3 of the polymorphisms: adenomatosis polyposis coli (APC)-I1307K (odds ratio [OR] = 1.58, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.21-2.07); Harvey ras-1 variable number tandem repeat polymorphism (HRAS1-VNTR; OR = 2.50, 95% CI: 1.54-4.05); and methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR)(Val/Val) (OR = 0.76, 95% CI: 0.62-0.92). For tumor protein 53 (TP53), N-acetyl transferase 1 (NAT1), NAT2, glutathione-S transferase Mu (GSTM1), glutathione-S transferase Theta (GSTT1), and glutathione-S transferase Pi (GSTP1) polymorphisms, the best estimates are sufficient to exclude a 1.7-fold increase in risk of colorectal cancer. CONCLUSIONS: APC-I1307K, HRAS1-VNTR, and MTHFR variants represent the strongest candidates for low penetrance susceptibility alleles identified to date. Although their genotypic risks are modest, their high frequency in the population implies that they may well have considerable impact on colorectal cancer incidence. Determining precise risk estimates associated with other variants and gene-gene and gene-environment interactions will be contingent on further studies with sample sizes larger than typically used to date.
About 5% of nonmedullary thyroid cancer is familial. These familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer cases are characterized by an earlier age of onset, more aggressive phenotype, and in some families a high propensity to benign thyroid disease. Little is known about the genes conferring predisposition to nonmedullary thyroid cancer. Three loci have been identified through genetic linkage: MNG1 on 14q32, TCO1 on 19p13.2, and fPTC on 1p21. In addition to these putative genes, a number of loci represent candidate familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer predisposition genes by virtue of their involvement in sporadic disease (TRKA), their role in benign disease (TSHR), and because they underlie syndromes with a risk of nonmedullary thyroid cancer (PTEN). To evaluate the roles of MNG1, TCO1, fPTC, PTEN, TSHR, and TRKA in familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer, we have carried out a comprehensive mutation and linkage analysis of these genes in 22 families. One family was linked to chromosome 19q13.2, confirming that TCO1 underlies a subset of familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer. None of the families was linked to MNG1 or fPTC, and there was no evidence to support the roles of PTEN, TSHR, or TRKA. Familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer is an emerging clinical phenotype that is genetically heterogeneous, and none of the currently identified genes accounts for the majority of families.
Juvenile polyposis syndrome (JPS) is an inherited hamartomatous-polyposis syndrome with a risk for colon cancer. JPS is a clinical diagnosis by exclusion, and, before susceptibility genes were identified, JPS could easily be confused with other inherited hamartoma syndromes, such as Bannayan-Riley-Ruvalcaba syndrome (BRRS) and Cowden syndrome (CS). Germline mutations of MADH4 (SMAD4) have been described in a variable number of probands with JPS. A series of familial and isolated European probands without MADH4 mutations were analyzed for germline mutations in BMPR1A, a member of the transforming growth-factor beta-receptor superfamily, upstream from the SMAD pathway. Overall, 10 (38%) probands were found to have germline BMPR1A mutations, 8 of which resulted in truncated receptors and 2 of which resulted in missense alterations (C124R and C376Y). Almost all available component tumors from mutation-positive cases showed loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in the BMPR1A region, whereas those from mutation-negative cases did not. One proband with CS/CS-like phenotype was also found to have a germline BMPR1A missense mutation (A338D). Thus, germline BMPR1A mutations cause a significant proportion of cases of JPS and might define a small subset of cases of CS/BRRS with specific colonic phenotype.
Juvenile polyposis syndrome (JPS; OMIM 174900) is a rare disorder which is characterized by the presence of hamartomatous polyps throughout the gastrointestinal tract and an increased risk of gastrointestinal malignancy. Mutations of the SMAD4 gene on chromosome 18q21.1 have been shown to cause a subset of JPS cases, with estimates ranging from 20% to >50%. Characterization of the genes that cause the remainder of JPS cases relies on the certainty that SMAD4 is not the causative gene. We have undertaken a comprehensive analysis of germline SMAD4 mutations in a cohort of JPS patients to define the spectrum of mutations that cause JPS. We have analyzed a series of polyps from these patients for SMAD4 protein expression. We have also performed a blinded assessment of polyp material to look for morphological differences between polyps from patients with and without a germline SMAD4 mutation. The results indicate that almost all germline SMAD4 mutations are readily detectable by screening genomic DNA using polymerase chain reaction-based methods; SMAD4 can be excluded as the causative gene in the majority of our JPS cohort. Loss of SMAD4 expression occurs in most polyps from SMAD4 mutation carriers, even those with missense germline mutations. SMAD4 loss in polyps is, however, not a feature of cases that are not caused by SMAD4 mutations, indicating that these polyps develop along a SMAD4-independent pathway. The morphology of polyps from SMAD4 mutation carriers is subtly different from other JPS polyps, notably including a more prominent epithelial component in the former.
Rare highly penetrant genes cannot account for much of the familial risk for most common cancers, and there is increasing evidence that a high proportion of cancers arise in a susceptible minority who carry low-penetrance genes or gene combinations. The evidence for the existence of such genes and the prospects for identifying them are reviewed.
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify published studies quantifying familial colorectal cancer (CRC) risks in first-degree relatives of CRC and colorectal adenoma (CRA) cases and, through a meta-analysis, obtain more precise estimates of familial risk according to the nature of the family history and type of neoplasm. METHODS: Twenty-seven case-control and cohort studies were identified, which reported risks of CRC in relatives of CRC cases and nine, which reported the risk of CRC in relatives of CRA cases. Pooled estimates of risk for various categories of family history were obtained by calculating the weighted average of the log relative risk estimates from studies. RESULTS: The pooled estimates of relative risk were as follows: a first-degree relative with CRC 2.25 (95% CI = 2.00-2.53), colon 2.42 (95% CI = 2.20-2.65), and rectal 1.89 (95% CI = 1.62-2.21) cancer; parent with CRC 2.26 (95% CI = 1.87-2.72); sibling with CRC 2.57 (95% CI = 2.19-3.02); more than one relative with CRC 4.25 (95% CI = 3.01-6.08); relative diagnosed with CRC before age 45, 3.87 (95% CI = 2.40-6.22); and a relative with CRA 1.99 (95% CI = 1.55-2.55). CONCLUSIONS: Individuals with a family history of CRC and CRA have a significantly elevated risk of developing CRC compared with those without such a history. Risks are greatest for relatives of patients diagnosed young, those with two or more affected relatives, and relatives of patients with colonic cancers.
OBJECTIVE: Coeliac disease (CD) shows a strong genetic predisposition involving HLA-DQ2 and non-HLA components. Tissue transglutaminase, encoded by TGM2, occupies a central role in the CD pathogenesis, necessary for the deamidation of specific glutamine residues of alpha-gliadin creating a T-cell epitope that binds with increased affinity to DQ2. To investigate whether germline mutations in TGM2 contribute to disease susceptibility we have carried out a comprehensive analysis of the gene in 52 patients with CD. DESIGN: Blood samples were collected from 52 children with biopsy proven CD attending one Swedish centre. DNA was extracted from lymphocytes and all exons and intron-exon boundaries of the TGM2 gene and the alternatively spliced form of the gene were screened for mutations. METHODS: Mutational analysis was undertaken by a combination of conformational specific gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing. RESULTS: Three novel polymorphisms were identified but no pathogenic mutations were detected. CONCLUSIONS: There is no evidence from this study that mutations in TGM2, which lead to an altered protein, contribute to CD susceptibility.
While screening for germline CHK2 mutations in cancer cases by heteroduplex CSGE, we observed that additional PCR fragments were generated from the 3' end region of the gene that includes exons 11-14. Direct sequencing of these fragments suggested that homologous loci (possibly pseudogenes) were concomitantly being amplified. Searches of public sequence databases showed that a number of areas of the genome show a high degree of homology to exons 10-14 of the CHK2 gene. The presence of these homologous regions means that standard screening methods for detecting mutations in CHK2, based on PCR of genomic DNA, are prone to error. To circumvent this problem, we have developed a strategy, based on long-range PCR, to screen the functional copy of CHK2. Using this approach it is possible to carry out a comprehensive mutational analysis of CHK2 from genomic DNA.
BACKGROUND: A genetic susceptibility to coeliac disease is well established, involving HLA and non-HLA components. CTLA4 is an important regulator of T-cell function and some studies have suggested that sequence variation in the gene might be a determinant of disease susceptibility, although the evidence is conflicting. METHODS: Sixty-two children with biopsy-proven coeliac disease attending a single centre in Sweden were studied. All were genotyped for presence of the HLA-DQA1*0501, B 1*0201 alleles. Those who carried the HLA-DQ heterodimer (58/62) were genotyped for the +49 (A/G) exon I polymorphism. The transmission disequilibrium test (TDT) was used to test for association between coeliac disease and the A allele. The entire CTLA4 gene was screened for other sequence variants using a combination of conformation-sensitive gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing. RESULTS: A significant association between the exon I polymorphism and coeliac disease was observed (P = 0.02). No other sequence variants in CTLA4 were detected. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides further evidence that variation in CTLA4 is a determinant of coeliac disease susceptibility. If not mediated through the +49 (A/G) dimorphism directly, then the effect is likely to be mediated through linkage disequilibrium.
Twelve to 16% of colorectal cancers (CRCs) display a high degree of microsatellite instability (MSI-H), whereas most are believed to be microsatellite stable (MSS). The existence of a low degree of instability (MSI-L) group has also been proposed. By using the Bethesda panel of microsatellite markers, the microsatellite instability (MSI) status of CRCs can be determined. This set is recommended to distinguish between MSI-H and MSI-L/MSS. No definition for MSI-L has emerged. Most reports on MSI-L rely on the Bethesda panel, using 5-15markers. Tumors with more than 30% MSI are designated as MSI-H, but the lower limit for MSI-L is ambiguous. We hypothesized that if many markers are studied, almost all CRCs would show some MSI. It would be necessary to establish a cutoff level for MSI-L by showing that, above this cutoff level, tumors display molecular and/or clinical features different from those under the cutoff level. To perform this task, we analyzed 90 BAT26 stable CRC samples with 377 markers. MSI at 1-11 loci was observed in 71 (79%) of the 90 cases. K-RAS mutation, loss of heterozygosity, and MLH1 and MGMT hypermethylation analyses were performed, as well as clinical features being scrutinized, to examine possible differences between MSI-L and MSS tumors using all of the possible cutoff levels for MSI-L. Convincing differences between putative MSI-L and MSS groups were not observed. Our results show that the sensitivity of a typically used marker number to detect MSI-L is very low, and they suggest that MSS and MSI-L tumors have a common molecular background.
Uterine leiomyomata (fibroids) are common and clinically important tumors, but little is known about their etiology and pathogenesis. We previously mapped a gene that predisposes to multiple fibroids, cutaneous leiomyomata and renal cell carcinoma to chromosome 1q42.3-q43 (refs 4-6). Here we show, through a combination of mapping critical recombinants, identifying individuals with germline mutations and screening known and predicted transcripts, that this gene encodes fumarate hydratase, an enzyme of the tricarboxylic acid cycle. Leiomyomatosis-associated mutations are predicted to result in absent or truncated protein, or substitutions or deletions of highly conserved amino acids. Activity of fumarate hydratase is reduced in lymphoblastoid cells from individuals with leiomyomatosis. This enzyme acts as a tumor suppressor in familial leiomyomata, and its measured activity is very low or absent in tumors from individuals with leiomyomatosis. Mutations in FH also occur in the recessive condition fumarate hydratase deficiency, and some parents of people with this condition are susceptible to leiomyomata. Thus, heterozygous and homozygous or compound heterozygous mutants have very different clinical phenotypes. Our results provide clues to the pathogenesis of fibroids and emphasize the importance of mutations of housekeeping and mitochondrial proteins in the pathogenesis of common types of tumor.
The molecular basis for most non-HNPCC familial colorectal cancer cases is unknown, but there is increasing evidence that common genetic variants may play a role. We investigated the contribution of polymorphisms in two genes implicated in the pathogenesis of colorectal cancer, cyclin D1 (CCND1) and E-cadherin (CDH1), to familial and sporadic forms of the disease. The CCND1 870A/G polymorphism is thought to affect the expression of CCND1 through mRNA splicing and has been reported to modify the penetrance of HNPCC. Inactivation of E-cadherin is common in colorectal cancer, and truncating germline mutations have been reported to confer susceptibility to colorectal as well as diffuse gastric cancer. The -160A/C CDH1 polymorphism appears to affect expression of CDH1 and may therefore also confer an increased risk. We found a significantly higher frequency of CCND1 870A allele in 206 familial cases compared to 171 controls (P=0.03). Odds ratios in heterozygotes and homozygotes were 1.7 (95% CI: 1.0-2.66) and 1.8 (95% CI: 1.0-3.3) respectively. The difference was accounted for by an over-representation of A allele in non-HNPCC familial cases (P=0.007). Over-representation of the CCND1 A allele was also seen in sporadic colorectal cancer cases compared to controls but this did not attain statistical significance (P=0.08). No significant differences between the frequency of CDH1 -160A/C genotypes in familial, sporadic colorectal cancer cases and controls were seen, although a possible association between the low expressing A allele and right-sided tumours was detected in familial cases.
PURPOSE: Estimates of familial colorectal cancer risks are useful in genetic counseling and as a guide to determining entry into screening programs and trials of chemoprevention. Furthermore, they provide an insight into the contribution of the known colorectal cancer genes to the familial risk of the disease. There is a paucity of data about the familial colorectal cancer risk associated with early-onset disease outside the recognized cancer predisposition syndromes. METHODS: This was a retrospective cohort study. The parents and siblings of 205 patients with colorectal cancer aged less than 55 years at diagnosis were studied for mortality and cancer incidence. RESULTS: The overall standardized mortality ratio of colorectal cancer compared with the Northern Irish population was 3.54 (95 percent confidence interval, 2.59-4.79). There was some evidence that a family history of colorectal cancer is associated with a greater risk of colon (4.16; 95 percent confidence interval, 2.83-5.91) rather than rectal cancer (2.62; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.43-4.40). Risks in parents (2.54; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.45-3.72) were lower than in siblings (6.15; 95 percent confidence interval, 3.90-9.23). CONCLUSION: First-degree relatives of patients with early-onset disease are at a marked increase in risk. There is evidence that risks vary depending on the type of affected relative and by the site of colorectal cancer. This information should be considered in formulating screening strategies.